Lo sviluppo della democrazia liberale: un itinerario da John Locke a John Stuart Mill

This entry is part 19 of 33 in the series Vol 2-2017

Abstract: This essay, from John Locke to John Stuart Mill, focuses on the development of the liberal tradition in politics. Much in the history of Liberalism was a set of important challenges to Hobbes’s emphasis on the necessity of an absolute sovereign. John Locke, for instance, argued for a limited sovereignty of which people were the true repository. But, the main problem of liberals was how to protect the right to the unlimited accumulation of private property basing, at the same time, their claims to liberty on the fundamental equality of all individuals. On the other hand, democrats had the problem of how to reach the right of all individuals to determine their lives where all possibilities of material well-being and progress were based on private property. For Mill, Liberalism needed Democracy. First, it needed Democracy for ethical reasons and, secondly, to avoid the total disaffection of the lower classes, the majority. His theory – affected by Bentham’s thought – is not based, like that of Hobbes or Locke, on the idea of certain inherent natural rights of the individual, but upon the doctrines of Utilitarianism. In Bentham’s view the obstacles to good government were the sinister interests of the ruling classes. In a democracy the ruling few could only further the interests of the whole community, because there were different kinds of institutional arrangements that limited the power of the rulers. Bentham thought that the rulers could still further their sinister interest even if there was a separation of powers and the good government was guaranteed only if the rulers followed the will of the people. The balanced constitution was the traditional answer to this problem, but Mill proved, that it would not work: the only way to guarantee good government was to create a system where the people elected their representatives. The chief mechanism for keeping the elected representatives in check was to have a short interval between elections.

View full Article in PDF

La teoria della relatività e l’eredità kantiana: logica, fisica e gnoseologia a confronto

This entry is part 18 of 33 in the series Vol 2-2017

Abstract: The comparison between Einstein’s relativity and Kant’s transcendental goes on a physical, logical and epistemological point of view. The critique of the transcendental implies a critique of the euclidean and not-euclidean geometry through the interpretation of Gödel and Cassirer. The analysis of special and general relativity is a great contribution to the knowledge.

View full Article in PDF

Empedocle e Freud. Riflessioni su logica e linguaggio

This entry is part 17 of 33 in the series Vol 2-2017

Abstract: The present piece, first presented on 19 November 2016 at the Centre Léon Robin (CNRS-Univ. Paris-Sorbonne-ENS Ulm) as part of the “Présocratiques” Seminar, is an investigation of the relationship between Empedocles and Freud. The analysis is divided into three parts: the first section examines the nature of Freud’s engagement with Empedocles; next, consideration is given to the similarities between their doctrines, based on the extant fragments of the Empedoclean corpus; finally, I offer a series of observations about Empedocles’ poetic style, which shares strong affinities with the spoken word in a manner typical of the oral tradition and is freighted with corporeal and emotional significance. It is here that we see the emergence of one of the key concepts of psychoanalysis: the relationship between logos and alogon, between that which can be rationally analysed and that which can be intuited but which eludes the domain of logos.

View full Article in PDF

Il bene del filosofo e il limite della città. Sulla politica filosofica di Leo Strauss

This entry is part 16 of 33 in the series Vol 2-2017

Abstract: The intention of this paper is to show how Leo Straussʼ mature writings respond to the twofold necessity of political philosophy: contributing, at the same time, to the good of the city and to the good of the philosophers. In the first place, it will try to prove this point by analyzing in detail the Introduction to On Tyranny (1948), which represents an essential step in order to understand the intention of the author. In the second place, it will tackle the problem of justice, that is, of natural right, by concentrating on the so called “tyrannical teaching”. This teaching is a way to present a truth which the city cannot find acceptable, that is, an unpleasant truth concerning the irresoluble problem of justice and legitimacy. In conclusion, it will point to the tension between philosophy, i.e., search for knowledge, and the city, i.e., the realm of opinion. For the philosopher, as such, has to “corrupt” the young in order to pursue his search for knowledge of the whole, or the nature of all things. Therefore, he weakens the city, since philosophizing implies unbelief in the gods of the city.

View full Article in PDF

Wittgenstein’s philosophy of seeing-as: multiple ways to philosophical perspicuity

This entry is part 15 of 33 in the series Vol 2-2017

Abstract: The article explores the broad issue of aspectuality in Wittgestein’s philosophy arguing that Kippbilder, aspect change, perception of aspect, aspect blindness and Bedeutungserlebnis are related to a meditation on specific forms of subjectivity. Analysing different grammatical configurations of ambiguous images in (visual, acustic, sensomotiric) perception, in language and in art he also shows how aspectual structures combine simultaneous perception of two elements (et-et model, for exemple physiognomy and its expression) and mutually exclusive aspect perception (aut-aut model as in the duck-rabbit Kippbild). Wittgenstein seems to believe that this double model somewhat challenges classical rationality and that aspectual experiences should have a more relevant place in our form of life.

View full Article in PDF

Una filosofia politica dell’«ombra» nella Spagna del XX secolo: da Miguel de Unamuno a Eugenio Trías

This entry is part 14 of 33 in the series Vol 2-2017

Abstract: Today, Spanish political philosophy provides very interesting keyes to understand some of the contemporary political processes as the decline of the West, Europe’s spiritual crisis, the weakness of liberalism and democracy. This paper will try to describe theoretical themes and literature suggestions about the shadow of history thanks to the original thought of some of 20th century most famous philosophers from Spain. First of all Miguel de Unamuno, the father of “tragic sense of life” who proposes an “agonic” philosophical approach to carry better sufferings and the problems of consciousness; then, we will talk about Ortega y Gasset his vital reason and particular way of liberalism; then, Xavier Zubiri, a very frequently forgotten philosopher who shakes up the ontology and epistemology by a new definition of reality; in closing, we will consider Eugenio Trías input on the philosophical analysis of power.

View full Article in PDF

Giustizia e libertà nel dibattito tra Rudolf Carnap e Karl Popper

This entry is part 13 of 33 in the series Vol 2-2017

Abstract: This paper explores some aspects of Carnap’s and Popper’s intellectual relationship focusing on Carnap’s appreciation of Popper’s critique of historicism which the Austrian philosopher developed in several contributions. The article also presents Carnap’s questioning about the Popper’s political and economic orientation suggesting that tha latter could implies a critical form of socialist society which firmly distanciate on the one end from radical forms of capitalism on the other and from the religious trust in socialism.

View full Article in PDF

A Different Way of Looking at United States Presidential Elections. A New Analysis of Political Science

This entry is part 14 of 31 in the series Vol 1-2016

Abstract: Every time the presidential election process begins, a question keeps troubling both scholars and citizens. «Does the best man go to the White House?». This essay obviously does not pretend to answer. It wants instead to offer a different point of analysis in order to fuel the debate. It’s not simple for an European citizen understand what is really happening. The way the American elections are conducted and presented has nothing to do with the European democratic involvement and television landscape. So, to try to understand what happens overseas this essay looks up to the movies that focus on the electoral competition. In fact, movies are more than a simple reflection of the citizens’ opinion. They also take part in the its formation and, so, they show those images which they have partly created themselves.

View full Article in PDF

Sul senso dell’invisibile in Kandinsky e in Malevič

This entry is part 13 of 31 in the series Vol 1-2016

Abstract: The works of Kandinsky and Malevich certainly represent some of the most radical attempts to redefine the essence and purpose of art, as part of the movement of cultural renewal that explodes in the first decades of the twentieth century. An attempt that has the virtue of having opened the path looking for that unheard and inaudible voice of art: that of its own inner sound, of its ‘invisible dimension’, as opposed to the alleged objectivity of the external world. That is why this effort can be read as an emblematic idea of a critique of modernity from the perspective of art. Not in vain has such a voice been a reference for many of the avant-garde movements of the twentieth century, although sometimes as a reaction to it, in an endless movement of construction and re-discussion of a new language and a new meaning for modern art.

View full Article in PDF

L’epigono dell’illuminismo scozzese: l’estetica di Archibald Alison

This entry is part 12 of 31 in the series Vol 1-2016

Abstract: Archibald Alison (Edinburgh, 1757-1839) adds a philosophical research to his ecclesiastical career, and in 1790 publishes a work which strikingly anticipates contemporary aesthetics, since it is founded on the notions of expression and emotion, which work together with the notions of imagination and association.

View full Article in PDF